Consumerism is a popular category of analysis, but what exactly does it mean? How is consumerism or the consumer society different from anything else? Haven’t every economies had producers and consumers?
In his The Romantic Ethic and the Spirit of Modern Consumerism , Colin Campbell offers this description of consumerism: “that distinctive cultural complex which was associated with the consumer revolution in eighteenth-century England, and which embraced the rise of the novel, romantic love and modern fashion, is related to the widespread adoption of the habit of covert day-dreaming. The central insight required is the realization that individuals do not so much seek satisfaction from products, as pleasure from the self-illusory experiences which they construct from their associated meanings. The essential activity of consumption is thus not the actual selection, purchase or use of products, but the imaginative pleasure-seeking to which the product image lends itself, ‘real’ consumption being largely a resultant of this ‘mentalistic’ hedonism. Viewed in this way, the emphasis upon novelty as well as upon insatiability both become comprehensible.”
Novelty is thus more important than utility, and even novelty is not so important as perceived novelty: “The fact that a so-called ‘new’ product may not, in reality, offer anything resembling either additional utility or a novel experience is largely irrelevant, as all real consumption is a disillusioning experience in any case. What matters is that the presentation of a product as ‘new’ allows the potential consumer to attach some of his dream pleasure to it, and hence to associate the acquisition and use of the object with realization of the dream. As soon as this identification has taken place, the product will be ‘desired,’ as some of that intense longing which is generated by the practice of day-dreaming becomes linked to the product in question.”
Peter Leithart
Peter J. Leithart is President of Theopolis Institute. He is the author of numerous books on theology, literature, and culture, including Theopolitan, Defending Constantine, and Baptized Body.
More from Economics
Continue reading related articles

Politics of Price
What determines prices? Supply and demand, says anyone with a modicum of training in economics. Right, says Barry C. Lynn ( Cornered ): "In any open market that is populated by many small buyers and many small sellers, if the producers try to raise their prices high enough to make…

Scarcity
Once, argues Nicholas Xenos ( Scarcity and Modernity ), “scarcity” did not exist. What existed with “scarcities,” or “periods of scarcity.” He writes, “Of medieval origin, ‘scarcity’ derives from the Old Northern French escarcete . Its original usage denoted an insufficiency of supply, and by the fifteenth century the word…

Between Garden and City
Andrew Kuiper offers a superb, exhilarating summary of Sergei Bulgakov’s Philosophy of Economy . Kuiper begins by summarizing Bulgakov’s case against “economism,” the assumption shared by free marketeers and Marxists that human beings are motivated above all by economic drives. For both, man is homo economicus . Bulgakov had read…
In Medias Res
Your weekly digest for all things Theopolis.