Henry Ansgar Kelly’s Ideas and Forms of Tragedy from Aristotle to the Middle Ages (Cambridge, 1993) is a careful and useful study of the use of the word “tragedy” from the ancients through the 14th century. He narrowly focuses on the uses of the word-group itself, and shows that the word meant many different things to different writers. Along the way, he makes a couple of important observations: a) Many writers in the later patristic period and the medieval period had virtually no idea of how tragedies were actually performed in the ancient world, and some had no idea that they were performed. b) Tragedy virtually disappeared during the medieval period, until revived in England by Chaucer (a revival examined in Kelly’s companion volume, Chaucerian Tragedy ). When medieval writers wrote of tragedy (and few actually did), they spoke of it as an obsolete genre, something done by the poets of antiquity but no longer practiced. c) The influence of Boethius on medieval notions of tragedy is very important. Intriguingly, Boethius characterizes the incarnation as a tragedy, apparently thinking of the “incarnation and passion to involve a fall of sorts” yet one that “had the happpy result that many were taken up into the Godhead.” Boethius maintained this favorable view of tragedy even he wrote about the connections between tragedy and fortune: “What else does the clamor of tragedies bewail,” he has Fortune say, “but Fortune overthrowing happy kingdoms with an unexpected blow.”
Kelly’s study is rich in specific details, and helps to clarify in what senses Christianity was and was not seen as compatible with tragedy.
Peter Leithart
Peter J. Leithart is President of Theopolis Institute. He is the author of numerous books on theology, literature, and culture, including Theopolitan, Defending Constantine, and Baptized Body.
More from Literature
Continue reading related articles

God's Plenty
A few thoughts on the “General Prologue” to Chaucer’s Canterbury Tales . 1) The Prologue sets the stage for a multi-layered set of tales. The real-life Chaucer is, of course, the author, but in the Prologue, he introduces a fictional version of himself as narrator: It happened in that season…

Violence as Poetry
Paul and Jane Sinclair, protagonists of J.G. Ballard’s 2000 novel Super-Cannes , move from England to the French Riviera to live at a new high-tech business park, Eden-Olympia (!), after Jane’s friend and former lover, Dr. David Greenwood, goes on a killing spree that ends with suicide. Jane, a pediatrician,…

Memento Mori
Virtually all the characters in Muriel Spark’s 1959 novel, Memento Mori , are over 70. They suffer the physical humiliations of aging and the pains of regret. Unexpectedly, hilariously, they’re as competitive and petty as schoolchildren. Well into his 80s, Godfrey Colston scorns the crippled critic Guy Leets for the…
In Medias Res
Your weekly digest for all things Theopolis.