In After God , Tristram Engelhardt notes that autonomy is not merely a source of authority in secular culture, but "a cardinal directing value or goal." In today's world, one is "obliged freely to choose in conformity with very particular understandings of freedom. The result is that morally condemning autonomously chosen, peaceable, secularly acceptable life-styles and death-styles is considered to be immoral because it involves a failure to accept others as free and equal sources of moral authority and personal moral worth" (248). Professionals are therefore obliged "to accord others not just a right to respect, but also to recognize their claim rights to autonomy and to offer social support for the dignity of their life-styles and death-styles." This puts traditional Christian health care providers in a bind: They "are condemned for their failure to support secularly accepted life-style choices, including homosexual life-styles." A physician who offered a patient a comparison of "the health risks of a male homosexual life-style" and the risks of "heavy smoking" would come under fire. Any "adverse judgment of a politically, that is, legally accepted life-style . . . will be construed as a form or morally prohibited intolerance and professional malfeasance. Indeed, traditional Christianity's 'intolerance' of such life-styles, if voice publicly, is judged to be an instance of hate speech, because such statements bring into question the moral rectitude of those exercising politically legitimate rights of self-determination" (248-9). Health care professionals have few choices. They can cheerfully conform to the standard of secular autonomy, and become active agents for secularizing health care. They can remain silent, and thereby become tacit agents for maintaining and advancing the secular consensus. They can buck the system and risk their livelihood and professional status. Few choices, none of them, good.
Peter Leithart
Peter J. Leithart is President of Theopolis Institute. He is the author of numerous books on theology, literature, and culture, including Theopolitan, Defending Constantine, and Baptized Body.
More from Medicine
Continue reading related articles

COVID Diagnosis
Whether they intend to or not, parents are training their children by the way they respond to COVID. Pastors are training their churches. There are temptations on every side. Put aside debates about the efficacy of masks, lockdowns, distancing, vaccines, and do some self-diagnosis: Will your response to the pandemic…

From Sword to Syringe
Stanford’s Jay Bhattacharya, Oxford’s Sunetra Gupta, and Harvard’s Martin Kulldorff are heroes of the COVID-19 pandemic. Last October, they teamed up to write the Great Barrington Declaration that advocated “focused protection” of the vulnerable as an alternative to generalized lockdowns. They’ve faced relentless scorn, slander, and censorship ever since, yet…

Distortions of Modern Medicine
A few highlights from the readings for Kimbell Kornu’s Pentecost Term course on "The Christian Art of Dying," which we hosted at Theopolis in May. 1. Christians agree that sin is the ultimate cause of illness. But George Khushf suggests another dimension of the sin-sickness relation: Illness as “general revelation.”…
In Medias Res
Your weekly digest for all things Theopolis.