Spenser might provide a Milbankian response to Milbank’s endorsement of homosexual sex and “threesomes.” In Book 3 of The Faerie Queene , Spenser’s heroine is Britomart, the lady knight who represents a militant chastity directed toward marital and sexual consummation rather than a fearful virginity that simply avoids sex. Britomart is descended from a Trojan, Brutus, the legendary founder of the British people. In one of her battles, she unseats Paridell, who is also of Trojan descent. Paridell is from the collateral line of Paris, and is altogether another Paris ?Eseducing Hellenore away from her husband Malbecco and causing disorder at least in Malbecco’s house. Paridell’s Trojanness is a static thing, a matter of identically repeating Paris’s original sin (to use Milbankian language). Britomart, on the contrary, is among the anscestors of Elizabeth, and thus is a link in the chain connecting Trojan virtue with Elizabethan virtue. Her Trojanness is not the identical repetition of the past sin and fall, but a non-identical repetition that leads to progress. And this progress, Spenser is at pains to show, depends upon her chastity (in the sense defined above).
If the details could be filled it, we might have a way to argue that non-identical repetition (Milbank’s Trinitarian ideal) depends on chastity, and thus on the renunciation of threesomes and homosexual sex. Apart from such chastity, cultures and persons are condemned to the static identical repetition that Milbank abhors. I have not even come close to identifying the dots here, much less connecting them, but perhaps Spenser provides the materials for a response to Milbank that works with Milbank’s own materials and concepts. Something for one better qualified than I to follow up with.
Peter Leithart
Peter J. Leithart is President of Theopolis Institute. He is the author of numerous books on theology, literature, and culture, including Theopolitan, Defending Constantine, and Baptized Body.
More from Literature
Continue reading related articles

God's Plenty
A few thoughts on the “General Prologue” to Chaucer’s Canterbury Tales . 1) The Prologue sets the stage for a multi-layered set of tales. The real-life Chaucer is, of course, the author, but in the Prologue, he introduces a fictional version of himself as narrator: It happened in that season…

Violence as Poetry
Paul and Jane Sinclair, protagonists of J.G. Ballard’s 2000 novel Super-Cannes , move from England to the French Riviera to live at a new high-tech business park, Eden-Olympia (!), after Jane’s friend and former lover, Dr. David Greenwood, goes on a killing spree that ends with suicide. Jane, a pediatrician,…

Memento Mori
Virtually all the characters in Muriel Spark’s 1959 novel, Memento Mori , are over 70. They suffer the physical humiliations of aging and the pains of regret. Unexpectedly, hilariously, they’re as competitive and petty as schoolchildren. Well into his 80s, Godfrey Colston scorns the crippled critic Guy Leets for the…
In Medias Res
Your weekly digest for all things Theopolis.