Let Each Esteem the Other Better
Having spent time in a number of different kinds of churches/denominations over the years, it has been my observation that in every group there are those with a healthy catholic attitude toward other Christians and also those with a proud and condescending attitude toward others who call themselves Christians.
If we are going to follow the Biblical admonition, we should consider the strengths of other kinds of Christians, and not only harp on our own. Since I live at present in the remnant of what was once Calvinism, let me look from a Calvinistic/Reformed/Presbyterian standpoint at the strengths of other kinds of Christians. We Calvinists can argue rather convincingly that our tradition provides the highest and most thoroughly Biblical understanding of God, the creation, and the God-man relationship. Thus far in Christian history, no one has provided a more consistently Biblical understanding of these matters than the Calvinist Cornelius Van Til.
But do Calvinists have good music? Not by Lutheran standards. To be sure, the Genevan Psalter began as a very powerful musical accomplishment, but by failing to allow for musical instruments (a Biblical must), the Calvinists by and large failed to mature musically. It was the Lutherans who developed congregational song, and though there have been ups and downs in that tradition over the years, they still have by far and away the best congregational music and liturgy.
Baptists are better at evangelism. It stands to reason, since they do not understand the covenant, and see “conversion” as the only way of salvation. Still, one finds large numbers of world missionaries and inner-city missions coming from Baptistic circles.
I should argue that Roman Catholics, because of their emphasis on charity, have outdone other Christians in setting up hospitals and mercy missions. When I was in Catholic school as a youngster (though a Lutheran on Sunday), we saw movies about St. Vincent and about Father Damien and the lepers on Molokai. Maybe Catholics have something to teach the rest of us about who real heroes of the faith are. Many Calvinists talk about good works, but seem overly busy telling us that they are optional and that we can be saved by faith alone without acting on our faith.
Methodists certainly outdid Calvinists in America. The Calvinists insisted on an “educated clergy,” which provided a filter that eliminated vast numbers of men with pastoral gifts in favor of a scholarly elite. Men concerned to build churches and save sinners went out and did so, and sadly reacted against the Calvinist snobs by becoming, sometimes, raving Arminians. But men are not saved by asking predestination into their hearts, and are not necessarily fed by clergy steeped in Latin and Greek.
In America, the Episcopalians have been able best to work with the halls of secular power. Since Jesus is lord of the nations, this is a positive aspect of the Episcopalian brand of the faith. Indeed, in their book The Power of their Glory , the Konoliges called America an “Episcocracy.” Democracy is a myth, and all societies are run by elites. I suspect that by and large Episcopalians understand that truth better than other American churches. Certainly, Episcopal church government is closer to the Bible, and has much wisdom to offer other groups.
Finally, and this of course is just a brief and suggestive essay, we can think of the enthusiasm of the Pentecostals. The original Genevan and Lutheran music was rhythmic (looking back to the Ars Nova of the High Christian Era), but this was soon lost. Nor did any of these churches recover the Biblical vision of lots of musical instruments. Indeed, if we are all Levites now, perhaps we should all (or all who are able) come to Church carrying our instruments with us. The Pentecostals and Charismatics, despite errors about “speaking in tongues,” have recovered that spirit. The texts they sing are often not profound, and their music is more like advertizing jingles than the kind of music the Psalter calls for, but having said all that, the enthusiasm and instruments are something we can all learn from.
I have started this discussion. Now perhaps others can chime in with other examples.
This article was originally published at the Biblical Horizons blog.
James B. Jordan is a contributor to Theopolis.
More from Biblical Horizons
Continue reading related articles

Priestly Animals
The first commandment given in the Levitical sacrificial legislation has to do with the animals appropriate to sacrifice: "When any man of you brings an offering to the Lord, you shall bring your offering of cattle ( behemah ), from the herd or the flock" (Lev. 1:2). Cattle alone were…

The Bible and Western Literature
The most cursory glance at the history of Western literature reveals that it has been deeply influenced by the Bible. Some of the greatest classics of Western literature draw their plots, characters, and ideas largely from Scripture; Dante’s Divine Comedy and Milton’s Paradise Lost are two of the most notable…

Broadening Our View of the Trinity
This article was originally posted in May of 1994. We speak of God as Father, Son, and Holy Spirit. The early Church tended to speak of Him as Father, Word, and Spirit. In this short essay, I want to suggest some other ways to think of the Trinity, ways that…
In Medias Res
Your weekly digest for all things Theopolis.