Reading Matthew, Identifying Discourses: A Closer Look at the “Six-Discourse” Proposal
In a February blog post for the Theopolis Institute, Benoît Engel offers a thought-provoking challenge to the widely accepted five-discourse structure of Matthew’s Gospel, proposing a sixth discourse in Matthew 21:28–22:14 to reframe the Gospel’s chiastic center. As someone deeply invested in Matthew’s literary design—explored in my book Reading Matthew, Trusting Jesus: Christian Tradition and First-Century Fulfillment —I find his creativity engaging. However, after careful consideration, I remain persuaded that the five-discourse model better reflects Matthew’s intentional structure. In this response, I’ll summarize Engel’s proposal, highlight its strengths, raise some concerns, and defend the five-discourse framework, hoping to contribute to this ongoing conversation about Matthew’s Gospel.
Engel’s Proposal: A Sixth Discourse
Engel questions the widely acknowledged, scholarly view that Matthew’s Gospel is structured around five great discourses (chs. 5–7; 10; 13; 18; 23–25), 1 suggesting that scholars have overlooked a sixth in 21:28–22:14 consisting of three consecutive parables (the two sons, the tenants, and the wedding feast). He argues that adding this discourse shifts the Gospel’s chiastic center from chapter 13 (a discourse) to chapters 14–17 (a narrative), resolving perceived imbalances in the widely acknowledged model. A simplified version of his structure, adapted from his post and presented alongside chapters of the five-discourse model, looks like this: 2
In Engel’s model, the sixth discourse (21:28–22:14, simplified as chapters “ 21b-22a ” above) balances the Gospel’s midsection, aligning chapters 14–17 as the literary pivot. Engel sees this as demanded by Matthew’s chiastic design, offering a new lens on the Gospel’s structure.
Strengths of Engel’s Proposal
Engel’s approach has several merits worth noting. First, it addresses a noticeable imbalance in the five-discourse model, where chapters 8–12 are shorter than 14–22, suggesting a more symmetrical center elsewhere. Second, his sixth discourse—three parables with Isaianic motifs (e.g., vineyards, wayward sons)—complements scholarship on Matthew’s typology, such as Peter Leithart’s view that Jesus recapitulates Israel’s history and figures like Isaiah. This typological link is a commendable insight. 3 Finally, Engel’s focus on 14–17 as a narrative-center forms a neat chiasm, with pericopes like Jesus’s suffering and resurrection foreshadowed alongside John the Baptizer’s martyrdom, 4 and Peter’s thoughts carrying him away alongside declarations of Jesus as the Son of God. 5 While I don’t fully agree with his 12-point chiasm for these chapters, 6 his observations here are intriguing and invite further reflection.
Reservations About the Six-Discourse Model
Despite these strengths, I have reservations about Engel’s proposal. The first has to do with literary balance issues. Engel aims to correct the imbalance between chapters 8–9 and 19–22 in the five-discourse model, where 8–9 is noticeably shorter (chs. 8-9 are almost half the length of chs. 19-22). However, by designating 21:28–22:14 as a discourse, he pairs 8–9 with 22:23–46 (see 22b of discourse c ' above), which is half the length of chapters 8–9—creating a new and seemingly identical disparity. In other words, Engel never actually gets rid of noticeable imbalance with a sixth discourse.
Similarly, pairing chapters 13 and 18 as corresponding discourses seems forced. Chapter 13, with its parables, proverbs, and wisdom-sayings for those interested in the kingdom’s secrets, differs thematically and contextually from chapter 18’s focus on apostolic leadership, mission, and warnings to not misuse and abuse the authority Christ gave them. Unlike the clear parallels between chapters 10 and 18 (both addressing apostolic leadership, mission, and division), 7 13 and 18 lack shared terminology or intent, suggesting they aren’t natural chiastic partners.
My second reservation is more critical and pertains to a lack of discourse markers and a noticeable literary seam. I don’t think there is a literary seam to be found around 21:28–22:14 (see 21b –22a of discourse d ' above), especially not one indicating that Matthew intends to identify these sayings as a sixth discourse. Clearly, 21:28–22:14 lacks the hallmarks of Matthew’s five undisputed discourses. Engel notes that he is aware of this. However, each of those (5–7; 10; 13; 18; 23–25) features opening remarks signaling an intentional sermon and crystal-clear closing formula (e.g., “When Jesus had finished these sayings”). In contrast, 21:28–22:14 emerges mid-conversation with the chief priests and elders (21:23ff), flowing naturally from narrative, and ends abruptly with the Pharisees’ reaction (22:15). Without distinct markers, there is no literary seam that shows a clear discourse. Moreover, 21:28–22:14 resembles other parabolic sayings scattered throughout Matthew’s narrative rather than a standalone discourse. For example, if all one has to do is find sayings as lengthy as 21:28–22:14, someone could suggest that 12:22–45 might be a seventh discourse; after all, the speech contained in 12:22–45 is very close to the same length of words as Engel’s suggested sixth discourse.
Defense of the Five-Discourse Model
I find the traditional five-discourse structure more compelling, with chapter 13 as its center and chapters 19–22 as a unified narrative. Chapter 13, the third discourse, sits at the Gospel’s midpoint, flanked by parallel pericopes about Jesus’ family:
12:46–50 : Jesus identifies his “mother,” “brothers,” and “sisters” as those who do his Father’s will (τοῦ πατρός μου).
13:1 –52 :[The central discourse]
13:53–58 : His “mother,” “brothers,” and “sisters” reject him in his “father-land” (τὴν πατρίδα αὐτοῦ).
These mirror each other thematically and textually, framing chapter 13 as the pivot. The surrounding narratives (11–12 and 14–16) also align in parallel patterns (not inverted parallel patterns, as chiasms are by definition), such as:
11:1–19 / 14:1–12 : John the Baptizer’s witness and martyrdom
11:20–24 / 14:13 –21 : Warnings of division vs. acts of compassion (feeding miracles)
11:25–30 / 14:22–36 : Jesus declared the Son of God and those blind to this truth
12:1 –8 / 15:1–20 : Pharisees accuse Jesus’ disciples of breaking Rabbinic tradition, and Jesus responds
12:9 –14 / 15:21–28 : The Pharisees’ hatred vs. the Canaanite woman’s great faith
12:15 –21 / 15:29–31 : Jesus withdraws; many follow him and he heals them
12:22 –37 / 15:32–39 : Warnings of division vs. acts of compassion (feeding miracles)
12:38–45 / 16:1–12 : Requests for a sign, answered with Jonah’s example
This symmetry, detailed in my book, reinforces chapter 13’s centrality without requiring a sixth discourse. 8
Chapters 19–22 form a cohesive narrative unit, bracketed by inclusios like “you shall love your neighbor as yourself” (19:19; 22:39) and vineyard parables (20:1–16; 21:33–44). Chapter 19 also begins with scenery that is peculiar to chapter 22, in which we find Pharisees approaching Jesus to test him (19:3; cf. 22:15). They ask Jesus about distinct topics related to marriage with multiple spouses and attaining eternal life, all the while arguing from the Torah along with Jesus (19:3–12, 16–22; cf. 22:23–40). Rhetoric about the “kingdom of heaven” (19:12–23; 22:1–2) and Jerusalem’s looming conflict (20:17–19; 21:33–44) are what weave this narrative section together.
After Jesus is tested by Pharisees, and after he argues with those twisting the Torah, and after he makes claims about the kingdom of heaven— all within chapter 19 and all themes that are mirrored in chapter 22—Matthew presents the reader with a parable from Jesus about a “master of a house” who owns a “vineyard.” Immediately after that parable, Jesus warns his disciples that the “son” of man is about to be killed in Jerusalem (20:1–19). This exact same imagery is mirrored immediately prior to chapter 22 where we find another parable about the “master of a house” who owns a “vineyard.” These are clear literary clues within one lengthy narrative . The mirroring of language and themes is identical . It’s not even remotely vague. In the end of that parable, the tenants of the vineyard want to kill the Master’s “son” (21:33–44) just as Jesus warned back in 20:18–19 . (Notice that 21:33–44 is part of a discourse according to Engel.)
By beginning chapter 19 the way chapter 22 ends, Matthew has clearly framed chapter 19 so that it sets the stage for upcoming confrontation in Jerusalem (e.g., chapter 23) among its ruling class . Splitting 21:28–22:14 as a discourse disrupts this flow, undermining Matthew’s clear progression from Galilee (19:1) to Jerusalem before the final discourse (chs. 23–25). 9
Conclusion: A Continuing Conversation
Engel’s six-discourse proposal sparks valuable reflection on Matthew’s structure and typology and demonstrates remarkable creativity. Yet, I find the five-discourse model—with chapter 13 as its heart and 19–22 as a narrative whole—more consistent with Matthew’s literary cues and intent. Its imbalances, like the brevity of 8–9, seem deliberate, serving the Gospel’s utilitarian design rather than an esoteric chiasm. I’d welcome Engel’s response to these observations, as Matthew’s artistry continues to inspire debate. For now, I leave readers to weigh these perspectives against the text itself, confident that both approaches enrich our understanding of this remarkable Gospel.
______________________________________________________________________________
Jonathan E. Sedlak is a graduate of the Theopolis Institute. He is an independent scholar based in Milwaukee, WI, and the author of Reading Matthew, Trusting Jesus: Christian Tradition and First-Century Fulfillment within Matthew 24–25 .
NOTES
Jonathan Sedlak is a contributor to Theopolis.
More from Matthew
Continue reading related articles

Mission Accomplished: John the Baptizer and the Highway to Holiness (Matthew 11:1–6)
Misreading Intent In the opening verses of Matthew 11, the reader is confronted immediately by John the baptizer who has been imprisoned since 4:12. John poses a question to Jesus, inquiring from prison as to whether or not he is Israel’s awaited Messiah or if they should anticipate another: “Are…

Testimonium Negativum: Josephus, Matthew’s Gospel, and New Evidence for the Coming Christ
1. Introduction In this article, I delve into some parallels found in the scholarly analysis of two important literary works: the Testimonium Flavianum by Josephus ( Antiquities 18.63–64) and the Olivet Discourse in the gospel of Matthew (Matthew 24–25). These texts have been at the center of countless academic discussions,…

Authority that Heals: Unpacking Matthew 4:18 – 10:4
Many years ago, while perusing Janice Anderson’s revised doctoral dissertation, Matthew’s Narrative Web: Over, and Over, and Over again , I was impressed by her attention to literary structures of repetition within and across Matthew’s Gospel. 1 Her research, in part, nudged me closer toward my present conviction that Matthew…
In Medias Res
Your weekly digest for all things Theopolis.